Classic Whoopie Pie
Claimed by both Maine and Pennsylvania Amish bakers, the classic Whoopie Pie reportedly gets its name from children shouting “Whoopie!” upon finding the treat in their lunchboxes. Two pillowy cocoa cake domes sandwich a generous swirl of fluffy marshmallow buttercream.
Prep 30 min
Cook 12 min
Total Time 42 min
Servings 12 servings
Ingredients
0 / 7 ingredients ready Scale Recipe
12 servings
Allergens
glutendairyeggs
Nutrition & Dietary Profile
Estimated per serving (~104 g) Halal Kosher Vegan Vegetarian Gluten-Free
Calories 360 kcal
Carbs 52.3 g
Sugar 33.3 g
Fat 16.7 g
Protein 4.1 g
Instructions
0 / 6 steps completed- 1Sifting Cocoa & Leaveners Whisk sifted 2 cups flour, 0.66 cup Dutch cocoa, baking soda, baking powder, and salt cleanly in a bowl.
- 2Creaming Butter & Brown Sugar Beat 1 stick softened butter and 1 cup dark brown sugar for 3 minutes until fluffy; beat in 1 egg and 1 tsp vanilla.
- 3Alternating Flour & Buttermilk-Coffee Alternate dry mix in 3 batches with 1 cup buttermilk-coffee mixture until thick, scoopable batter forms.
- 4Piping Uniform Domes & Baking Fast Pipe 24 round 2-inch mounds spaced 2 inches apart on parchment; bake at 375°F (190°C) for 10–12 minutes until tops spring back softly; cool completely.
- 5Whipping Fluffy Marshmallow Filling Beat remaining stick of butter with powdered sugar 2 minutes until smooth, then beat in marshmallow crème, remaining vanilla, and pinch salt until cloud-light.
- 6Sandwiching Matched Cake Halves Pair cooled cakes by size, pipe tall mounds of marshmallow cream onto flat bottoms, cap gently with matching domes, and chill 20 minutes to set.
Chef's Masterclass Guide: Gear, Cues & Storage
Required Equipment & Pan Size
- 2 inches baking pan lined with parchment, electric hand/stand mixer
- Fine flour sieve, rubber spatula, toothpick tester & cooling rack
Doneness & Texture Checkpoints
- Toothpick near the center emerges clean (or with moist fudge crumbs where noted) after 12 min at 375°F
- Top crown springs back gently when pressed lightly with a fingertip
Pro Tips & Troubleshooting
- Bring refrigerated eggs and dairy to room temperature 1 hour ahead for smooth emulsion
- Stop mixing immediately once dry flour streaks vanish to keep sponge pillow-tender
Serving & Storage Guide
- Cool at least 20–30 min before slicing neatly into 12 portions
- Keep frosted cakes refrigerated 3 days; store plain or nut cakes airtight 4 days at room temp
12:00